Is GEO > SEO? Why Executive Focus Must Shift
November 12, 2025
Alexis Gunn
AI Prompt Design & Content Specialist
Alexis Gunn is an AI Prompt Design and Content Specialist at Sitation, where she leads initiatives at the intersection of artificial intelligence and content strategy. Leveraging a strong foundation in communication and program development, she crafts inclusive, precise content that supports both human understanding and AI optimization. Her expertise includes prompt design and cross-functional enablement, translating business goals into scalable processes.
Alexis earned both her Master of Education and Bachelor of Science in Communication Studies from Grand Valley State University. She currently lives in Detroit, Michigan, with her German Shepard, Stella. In her free time, she enjoys reading, baking sweet treats, and going out on her family’s boat.
Part 2 of our GEO deep dive series continues to explore how brands can thrive when search becomes a conversation. New to the series? Read Part 1 first to see how it all begins.
Treat GEO as a revenue program, not a content cost center.
Search has become a conversation. Models compress the shelf into a single answer, followed by a few recommendations. If your products are not included in those answers, you do not exist in the moment of choice. Winning now depends on signals that large models can parse and trust, not only on what ranks in traditional SERPs.
What Makes GEO Different from SEO
SEO earns a click. GEO earns the answer. GEO adds the signals that put your product name inside AI-generated responses, alongside continued SEO fundamentals. That means benefit-driven copy, consistent product data, and proof from reviews that echo how shoppers actually ask questions.
Treating GEO as a program ties work to measurable revenue. Measure inclusion in answers, phrase coverage in reviews, and conversion lift after PDP updates. Run this as a loop by season and audience, not as a one-off content push.
SEO earns a click. GEO earns the answer.
How to Shift the Strategy
Fund Three Workstreams
1. Authority: Be Cited Where Models Look
Models weigh trusted external sources such as high-authority review sites, retailers, and communities like Reddit. Presence across multiple credible sources raises confidence and increases the likelihood your brand will be named. Prioritize buying guides, comparisons, and expert AMAs that create quotable answers, then amplify authentic community threads.
- KPI Examples: Share of answers referencing your brand site, number of high authority mentions per priority SKU, and community conversation quality.
- Leadership Actions: Sponsor expert-led AMAs in relevant subreddits, publish “which product for X” articles on your site, and boost authentic threads where users already praise your products.
2. Structure: Make Data Machine Legible
LLMs will not quote what they cannot parse. Complete and consistent attributes, clear naming, and clean feeds across every retailer reduce exclusion risk. Align schema and PDP essentials to the way shoppers ask. Keep content fresh and synchronized across channels.
- KPI Examples: Attribute completeness by SKU, feed synchronization rate across retailers, and inclusion in retail AI answers for target queries
- Leadership Actions: Enforce naming conventions, centralize updates in the PIM, and standardize PDP bullets that mirror common use cases like “left handed” or “no smudge”
3. Proof: Operationalize Review Language
Models life phrases from reviews to justify recommendations. Ask simple, honest post-purchase questions that elicit benefit-rich language, then ensure PDP copy reflects those outcomes. Treat review operations as revenue operations.
- KPI Examples: Review volume and recency, percentage of reviews mentioning targeted benefits, and answer inclusion rate movement for those benefits
- Leadership Actions: Add two or three review prompts per SKU that capture how buyers actually use the product, then track whether Rufus or Sparky includes your SKUs more often for those queries
Operate GEO as a Seasonal Loop
This loop should be run by a small cross-functional pod across Sales, Marketing, and E-Commerce, with each team activating the same lifecycle through its own medium.
- Pick a season and primary audience, such as students, teachers, or procurement buyers.
- List five to seven exact questions they ask and write a one-line promise that answers them.
- Update titles, three bullets, images, and attributes to match.
- Run matching retail and community activations.
- Measure inclusion, key phrases, and conversion, then roll the learning into the next season. Focus wins.
Apply the Two Shelf Strategy
To win on both the influence shelf and the transaction shelf, open web AI values authority and credible citations. Retail AI values PDP quality, structured data, and reviews. Align the brand story externally and the product truth internally. Track separate levers and join them at answer inclusion.
Executive Takeaway
In the coming year, hold the three funded workstreams to revenue outcomes. Create authority and earn citations across trusted sources and communities. Measure brand mentions in answers and high authority coverage. Improve structure by enforcing complete attributes and clean, synchronized feeds. Measure attribute completeness, feed freshness, and retail AI inclusion for target queries. Systematize review prompts and monitor benefit language to prove your claims. Measure review phrase coverage and answer inclusion rate.
Implement a seasonal loop pattern that is natural to your industry and prioritize a plan that addresses both the retail and platform AI.
Here’s Bottom line: Authority without structured product signals is wasted. LLMs cannot recommend what they cannot parse. Treat GEO as a revenue program and run the loop every season to increase inclusion, conversion, and share.
Contact us for support as you shift your strategy focus.